Congress is currently considering two new bills the PROTECT-IP Act and the Stop Online Piracy Act (SOPA). This bills, heavily lobbied for by the movie and music industries, are intended to make it easier to stop the online piracy of music, movies, book, and games. This is certainly a reasonable goal, piracy is bad for business and a problem that an ISP like us has to deal with on nearly a weekly basis.
But, the approach taken by PROTECT-IP Act and Stop Online Piracy Act (SOPA) attempts to solve the problem of piracy by putting in a system for censoring the Internet. This is extremely problematic from the outset, an “IP rightsholder” simply has to claim a site is infringement on their property which will require ISPs to block the site and credit card processers to suspend doing business with the company that runs it. That’s it, no court involvement, no due processes. It’s up to the accused to prove their innocence after their site is blocked.
But, in my opinion, far worse is the mere creation of the infrastructure to censors the Internet in the U.S. (this is the same sort of technology already in use in China and Iran). Sure, it’s intended to stop piracy today, but it can be used to block any site for any reason. Once it’s there the temptation to use it will be impossible to resist. Power corrupts, and this is great power.
But, don’t take my word for it, read up:
There’s an open letter to Congress from the likes of Google, Microsoft, Ebay, Facebook, and Twitter.
The Electronic Frontier Foundation gives examples of popular sites that would be at risk from SOPA.
Tech site Ars Technica is not a fan.
Tumblr doesn’t like it so much they are spending their money to make it easy to call your representative.
So, please read up and, if you think this is a dangerous path, please call your representative and tell them what you think.